When Your Mother-In-Law Seems Impossible

Your mother-in-law says something that feels like:a) aexamples of responses that aim to employ the Aikido
put down,b) painful criticism,c) intrusive advice,d) anprinciple to discharge the energy of the attack and turn
insult,e) a crazy woman speaking.the conversation in a more fruitful direction:
Will you yell, sneer, show anger or leave the room? Do1. Substitute curiosity for resistance. "Hmmm, you think
you cry, sulk or put on a wounded dog look? Are you(repeat the offending comment). Tell me why you think
sarcastic, aggressive or just stubbornly silent? Thesethat way since I know your son (or daughter) doesn't
responses may seem reasonable, but anotherthink that way at all."
approach may be more effective. You could refuse to2. Acknowledge difference and explore it. "It seems,
respond to aggression with aggression. You could, oddthat we have different values. That isn't good or bad, it
as it may sound, practice the principles of Aikido.is just different. Can we learn to accept our
Aikido, one of the martial arts, is a way of defendingdifferences?"
oneself while also protecting the attacker from injury.3. Give honor and ask to be honored. "I respect your
The word Aikido, Wikipedia says, may be translatedlife since from it has come the person I have chosen
as "the Way of harmonious spirit."to marry. Now I ask you to respect the way we live
Okay, you may be wondering why you want toour lives. We want you in our life, but we need you to
protect from harm someone who just insulted you.allow us to make choices that are right for us without
Unless your mother-in-law really is a crazy woman,feeling judged or criticized. When we need your good
there is a good chance that her statement has less toadvice, I promise we will ask."
do with you than with her. Some hurt she holds within4. Frame the conversation you wish to have. "You
her may prompt her disagreeable behavior. The oddsknow, I so much want to have a good relationship with
are quite good that while the hurt may have beenyou. I know it matters to your daughter (or son), but it
triggered by you, it was not caused by you.matters to me as well. Can we discuss what we need
Mother-in-law behavior that seems inexplicable mayto do to make that happen because we are not
arise from inappropriate assumptions about the wayheaded in that direction now?"
the world should be. When the world does not backIn an upsetting moment, it can be hard to gather our
her up, your mother-in-law may feel hurt and blamewits, find our voice and respond without
you. Never mind whether this is fair or not, it is a realitydefensiveness. If we feel hit, the natural urge is fight or
you have to deal with. So how you can deal with it in aflight. But with a bit of mental preparation and some
way that does the least damage to both of you?deep breaths, it is possible to turn the discussion to
Aikido is not turning the other cheek or passivelygood end. To do so, we have to be able to "go to the
ignoring the intention to harm. Rather, it invitesbalcony," that is, to rise above what is happening on
engagement--an engagement that turns the attacker'sthe ground, watch it with a distance that gives us
momentum to your benefit. Here is a way tosome perspective and decide how to respond with
understand the concept: You push me, I push back.our evolved brain, not our mammalian brain.
We are locked in a pushing match. Instead, if you pushWill trying to follow Aikido principles always work?
me, I step to the side. I use no energy, and you areProbably not, but there is a very good chance that it
suddenly off-balance.can improve the dynamic and produce better behavior
How can we step aside or use the force of heron all sides. When we speak authentically to one
attack to turn the mother-in-law in a different direction?another, when we speak with love and not fear or
How might Aikido offer a more productive way ofanxiety, we can truly communicate, not just send
dealing with hurtful comments? Here are a fewwords in each other's direction.