Kata - Training Tool Or Waste of Time?

Gichin Funakoshi reportedly spent the first 10 years ofthe first section. I've written about power breathing
his karate training practicing nothing but Nianchibefore so I'll not go into it here, but needless to say the
(sometimes called Tekki Shodan). Sanshin (or SamKata assisted in building strength in my midsection
Chien) appears throughout the southern Chinesewhich helped the damaged back repair itself more
martial arts as well as Okinawan and Japanese karatequickly. Because I trained this kata daily, I started to
where it is often the first and last thing studentsreally recognize some of my favorite techniques were
practice in their training. To learn Wing Chun Kung Fucontained within it's moves.
you must spend at least one year mastering each ofWhen I'm not teaching, I work in security. One of my
it's three forms.favorite "come along" holds is a straight arm barred
Each of the above examples shows how prevalentacross my chest, the shape I make when applying the
Kata is in the martial arts. Yet many today choose tohold is in the first section of Seisan. This is just one of
shun their Kata practice saying it is useless and wastemy applications to this movement, I also have others,
of their time. Why is this? If Funakoshi spent 10 yearsit's the in-out parry defense, it's a goose neck wrist
on one Kata, and Wing Chun insists you master onelock, it's a sweeping parry with counter strike, it's a
form for an entire year before learning the next, theretake down. You may have completely different ones,
must be something in it. Are we missing the point? Independent on your style of fighting.
our wisdom have we lost touch with a valuable, if notNever the less, Seisan, to me, is a gold mine of
vital component of our martial arts?information and suits my personal style of martial arts.
The problem I find is two fold.As a note, you can see me perform Seisan on the
1 - Ring Sports and combat athletics are the popularwildgeesma YouTube page, the video is entitled "old
front of martial arts, spectators don't want to see aschool core training". One commenter posted regarding
flawless solo performance, they want to see a fight.my stance, another saying I was doing karate a
2 - Instructors so often haven't a clue what it is theydisservice to karate. I asked both to expand their
are teaching, martial arts have suffered in a globalcomments to get a better idea of their thoughts. Since
game of Chinese whispers with more information lostneither have bothered I can only assume they view
every generation.kata practice in the typical view points prevalent today
But what are Kata and what are they for?and show no understanding of the practice of Kata
An individual Kata (or form, Sayaw, pattern, whateverinstead choosing to focus on it's aesthetic properties.
the name...) or indeed a sequence of Kata such as inFighting is not aesthetically pleasing, it is brutal and
Wing Chun or Karate's Pinan (Hein) series, wereviolent.
originally formulated to assist in the training of a fightingDo ring sports use kata? Yes, but they call it by a
system. Each kata/sequence is in itself a completedifferent name, "shadow boxing". Is shadow boxing not
system of fighting. Masters would either teach a kata,kata? Of course it is, practicing a sequence of moves
or on occasion the kata would be formulated by thewith perfect execution, this is kata. While most will
student, in order for the student to be able to practiceshadow box with random strikes, the champions use it
solo and to have a reference for his techniques.as an opportunity to drill their best combinations.
The moves within a kata would be taught in detail andThe inspiration for this article actually came about after
applications explored and tested in live sparring.a conversation with Richie "The Sherriff" Carton. Richie
Sections of the kata would be taken and would formteaches the Tues and Thursday kickboxing at WGMA
the core of an entire training session, a particularHQ. Over the years Richie has himself won several
posture would be broken down so that it could betitles and has trained many fighter to title wins. His
trained from the ground up. Is the stance strong, is themost recent success is Ronan McSweeney who
bodies structure properly aligned, how can I generatecame home from Belfast last December after winning
maximal power at the beginning, middle and end of thethe World Super Welterweight Title as well as a
move. What would be the effects of this on mycouple of other belts from his opponent.
training partner (and so how would I expect it to workWhile chatting with Richie I discovered that he had
in a real scenario).instructed Ronan in four combinations. It was these
No move would have been meaningless. Even thefour combinations that won the fight. It occurred to me
smallest of moves would be seen for it's striking,then that the first Kata in the Carton kickboxing
locking, throwing or defensive possibility. Each movesystem may have just been created.
would have several applications, maybe against aThink about it, Ronan trains these four combinations
charge it's an avoidance, against a grab it's a throw,over and over until they become ingrained into his
against a punch it's a counter attack. Could it be usedpersonality, he then goes out to fight and without
on the ground? Well they'd find out.having to consciously think about them, they just come
Suddenly the kata is no more just an empty dance, it isout at the right time, reflexively. This is how kata is and
a library of real fighting techniques, applicable andalways was meant to work.
useful in a real street encounter.So who out thereIf Ronan took the time to put the four combinations
does this in their own training? Very few of you Iinto an easy to remember sequence, I'm sure it would
imagine.soon become the same useless imitation of martial
While there are a couple of names that have becomearts that most other katas hae become over time. But
synonymous with the rebirth of practical kata trainingright now, at least to Ronan (and to his opponent) this
(Iain Abernethy being the most prevalent, if you cankata is alive.
get hold of his books and dvd's, I recommend you doAt the beginning of the article I asked if Kata was a
so) the majority of instructors just show you thevaluable tool or a waste of time. I don't know if I've
moves, you copy them and then you go on and learnanswered the question for you, but I hope I've given
another kata, then another. By the time I was awardedyou room to think.
my 1st Dan in Wado Ryu I knew around 12 kata, 10If you practice kata, I want you to look at it with fresh
years later I was up to around 20 or so. Today I onlyeyes. Check what moved you use most in your
do maybe 5. But I am really getting to know these 5,sparring/tournaments/real world scenarios, see if you
they are no longer empty sequences.can recognize these shapes in any of your kata. The
Take Wado Ryu's Seisan kata for instance. I startedkata that contains the most relevant shapes, that's the
back with this one after injuring my back lifting weightsone that represents your style.
that were too heavy. The reason I would train SeisanKeep training and keep learning.
was primarily for the breathing and tension involved in