Is One of the Most Dangerous Kicks in Martial Arts Useless?

Whether in a martial arts class, a self defense class, orwon't stop an attacker?
practicing on one's own, we all practice this specificDo they think that a "woman" couldn't get a hit in during
martial-arts kick over and over. Yet now, a bunch ofa real attack? (Sexists!)
discussion groups are saying that this kick (or even aDo these martial-arts forum members feel that a
punch) is useless for women as a self-defensevictim would be too afraid to respond?
strategy. Do you use this move? Does it work forThe expert martial artists feel that it's a combination of
you?several factors:
Defending Against a Rape Attempt- Most women who are attacked do not have
For the past month, I have been doing a little forumextensive(sufficient) self defense training
reading (lurking). Very interesting.- Many male attackers can overpower a woman.
Many martial artists make a conclusion that hitting orBigger, more powerful, etc.
kicking the groin is useless as a defense to being- Any attempt at a groin strike would be easily
attacked. Yes, they really do believe this.blocked.
Let me explain:- If a woman attempts to strike the groin, the
The thread usually starts with someone asking forramifications of not incapacitating the attacker could be
opinions on an attack requiring a self-defenseworse (if that's imaginable).
response. The poster (male or female) wants to knowIs a Hit or Kick to the Groin Effective?
the best response for a woman who has to defendSo, is a groin strike an effective move? Will it work?
herself against a rape attempt.Could it stop an attacker?
Some martial artist responds with suggestions of eitherThe short answer is that striking the groin "can" indeed
hitting or kicking the groin.end a fight. Although, the hit has to be delivered with
Then the rest of the forum members criticize thethe right pressure - light taps work - a heavyhit can
response as being just about 100% ineffective. What?cause the body to go into shock and ignore the pain -
Why Wouldn't a Hit to the Groin Work?a really hard, smashing hit could knock the attacker
I thought that groin kicks and hits were some of theunconscious.
best techniques for practical martial arts. Was IAfter you understand the proper hitting force, the
wrong?question really becomes - can the victim reach the
Do these martial artists feel that groin kicks and hitsgroin with a hit or kick?